Reservoir System Operating Plan
Introduction
The Wisconsin River Headwater Reservoir System consists of 21 storage reservoirs used to control the flow of the Wisconsin River. The reservoirs are owned and operated by Wisconsin Valley Improvement Company (WVIC), a private corporation chartered by the Wisconsin Legislature in 1907. Sixteen of the reservoirs are natural-lake reservoirs created by building dams at the outlets of natural lakes. The remaining five reservoirs are artificial, engineered reservoirs created by building dams at locations where no lake existed naturally.
WVIC’s reservoir dams do not contain hydroelectric generating facilities. The system is licensed by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) because the Wisconsin River is a navigable waterway and the operation of the reservoirs increases generation for the 25 hydroelectric dams on the Tomahawk and Wisconsin Rivers. The 25 hydroelectric dams are not owned or operated by WVIC and are either separately licensed by FERC or exempt from FERC licensing.
The reservoir system is operated for the purpose of making the flow of the Wisconsin River as uniform as possible. If the reservoir system capacity was unlimited and controlled in the entire drainage basin, a truly uniform river flow could be produced. However, the reservoir system capacity is finite and controls only about one-sixth of the drainage basin. Therefore, river flow cannot be made completely uniform at all locations. Instead, the reservoir system is operated in an annual cycle, in response to seasonal changes in hydrologic conditions, to maximize the uniform flow objective while also considering recreational and environmental factors.
The original FERC license for the project expired in 1993. During the relicensing process involving WVIC, FERC, and numerous other resource agencies and public groups, a new license was issued to WVIC in July 1996. The new license contains specific operating rules for the reservoir system that were designed to balance the many benefits of the system including hydropower production, flood control, and recreation, while at the same time protecting water quality and fish and wildlife resources.
Operating Plan
The specific operating rules for the reservoir system are specified in FERC License No. 2113 issued July 17, 1996, and modified by subsequent orders. There are four components of the operating plan which are specified in various license articles. Taken together, these four components define the operating plan.
1. Maximum and minimum water levels in each reservoir (Article 403)
2. Minimum flow for each reservoir (Article 404)
3. Flow goals (Article 412)
4. Storage balancing using index levels (article 412)
The operating plan can generally be described as follows:
Target river flows, or flow goals, are set for two locations on the Wisconsin River. These goals are set based on time of year and available storage in the reservoirs.
Reservoir storage is managed to meet the Flow Goals. If natural river flow is above the flow goals because of rainfall or snowmelt, water is stored in the reservoirs. If natural river flow is below the flow goals because of dry conditions, water is released from the reservoirs.
Storage is balanced between the reservoirs by assigning Index Levels to various water levels in each reservoir. The amount of water released from each reservoir is managed to keep all reservoirs at the same index level, if possible.
Each reservoir has maximum and minimum water levels that cannot be exceeded.
Each reservoir has a minimum flow that is generally released at all times, unless WVIC’s Drought Contingency Plan is enacted.
Each component of the operating plan is explained in detail in the following sections.
Flow Goals
Flow goals are target flows on the Wisconsin River. Flow goals are set for two locations on the river: Merrill and Wisconsin Rapids. The twenty northern reservoirs are operated to achieve the flow goal at Merrill. The Eau Pleine Reservoir supplements the operation of the northern reservoirs to achieve the flow goal at Wisconsin Rapids during summer and fall. Both the Eau Pleine Reservoir and the DuBay Hydroelectric Project are used to meet the flow goal at Wisconsin Rapids during late winter and early spring.
Two different techniques are used to set flow goals depending on the time of year, as described below.
Merrill Flow Goals
Wisconsin Rapids Flow Goals
Spring-Summer-Fall (April-October)
Flow goals during spring, summer, and fall are set using rule curves. Rule curves are mathematical formulas that allow WVIC to calculate the flow goals using two factors: date and current water storage volume in the reservoirs. The rule curves vary by month to account for the changes in meteorological and hydrologic conditions that occur between spring, summer, and fall.
The rule curves have a lower bound that is set to protect water quality on the Wisconsin River, since very low flows can result in low dissolved oxygen and poor water quality. As reservoir storage volumes increase, flow goals increase because more water is available for river flow augmentation. The rule curves also have an upper bound set to conserve water in case drought conditions develop.
During runoff events, river flows can exceed the flow goals for two reasons: the reservoirs may be full and unable to store more water, and runoff from the many unregulated waterways that drain into the Wisconsin River are increasing the flow.
Winter (November-March)
Dependent on hydrological conditions, flows during winter are set to reach minimum storage volumes in the reservoir system by the end of March while at the same time providing uniform river flow. This is done by calculating the current available reservoir storage, proportioning this storage amount over the number of days until the end of March, and supplementing this amount to the expected natural river flow for the winter season. This calculation is updated throughout the winter.
The amount of snow water equivalent (SWE) that accumulates in the snowpack is monitored throughout the winter season. If the snow water content is running below normal, the end-of-winter target reservoir elevation will be raised to preserve available water, and the winter flow releases will be lowered. The preserved water is then used to supplement the spring refill of the reservoir system.
The expected natural flow used in the winter flow goal calculation is updated throughout the winter season on the basis of observed natural flow.
WVIC files an annual report with FERC documenting actual daily river flows at the United States Geological Survey (USGS) gages at Merrill and Wisconsin Rapids. Any flows that are 15% below or 15% above the flow goal are defined and detailed in the annual Operations Report.
Storage Balancing Using Index Levels
Index Levels are numerical values that represent reservoir surface elevations that correspond to specific reservoir storage volumes. They are a means to equitably manage and balance water storage across our entire reservoir system in a hydrologically, environmentally, and recreationally sound manner.
WVIC’s FERC license designates six "index levels" to represent storage in each of the reservoirs and then operates the reservoirs in a manner that keeps all reservoirs as close to the same index level as possible. The index level method of storage balancing has been used by other agencies including the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
The relationship of the index levels to usable storage and water level varies from reservoir to reservoir. Many factors, including the interrelationships of the reservoirs, the hydrologic characteristics of each reservoir's drainage basin, and each reservoir's individual recreational and environmental resources were considered along with hydropower in setting the proposed index levels.
WVIC files an annual report with FERC documenting actual index levels. Any index level variations of more than 1 index level are defined and detailed in the annual Operations Report.
For an example of how WVIC manages reservoir index levels, click here.
Spirit Index Levels
Eau Pleine Index Levels
Eau Pleine Index Levels
Willow Index Levels
Rice Index Levels
Maximum and Minimum Water Levels for Each Reservoir
Maximum and minimum allowable water levels are specified in the FERC license for each reservoir. These water level limits cannot be exceeded to meet flow goals or balance index levels. However, the limits may be temporarily modified if required by operating emergencies beyond the control of WVIC, scheduled maintenance, and for short periods upon agreement from the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
If the water level limits are exceeded, WVIC files a written report with FERC that identifies the cause of the problem and describes corrective measures that have been taken to prevent future problems.
Reservoir Water Level Limits
Minimum Flows
WVIC releases a site-specific continuous minimum flow from each reservoir to enhance recreational use and protect aquatic life in the river downstream from the dam. Minimum flows are measured either in cubic feet per second (cfs) of river flow or inches of gate opening at the dam. Discharges cannot be reduced below minimum flow to meet flow goals, balance index levels, or prevent reservoir water levels from dropping below allowable minimums. However, the discharge may be reduced below minimum flow temporarily during emergencies beyond WVIC's control or upon agreement from the US Fish & Wildlife Service and the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
If discharges fall below minimum flow, WVIC files a written report with FERC that identifies the cause of the problem and describes corrective measures that have been taken to prevent future problems.